Convector or radiator: what is better, comparison, pluses and minuses

With the onset of cold weather, it is often necessary to provide additional heating in various rooms. In some country houses, there is no central heating at all. In this case, we have to look for alternative ways to heat the living quarters. Most often the choice falls on a convector or radiator. ? Which is better ? Users have different opinions.

The best type of heating should be efficient, reliable and economical. What devices meet these requirements are discussed below.

Main types of heaters

Today on the shelves of specialized stores there are many different types of heaters. First of all, they are allocated according to the type of fuel used, which is necessary for injecting a certain temperature.

, УФО, напольные кабельные системы. Electric types include convector, oil cooler , UFD, floor cable systems. The advantage of such heaters is the availability of electricity. Even in a country house, you can use this energy source to make both comfortable and basic heating.

The hotel group includes convectors heating water. потребителей дают понять, что этот тип обогревателя применяется для обустройства автономного отопления. Comments from consumers make it clear that this type of heater is used to arrange autonomous heating. But its installation can take a lot of time and effort. Warm water or liquid inside the radiators boilers. They can work on solid fuels, gas, agricultural waste, and so on.

For residents of cities and owners of country houses, who want to purchase an additional device in support of basic heating, electric convectors or oil coolers are more suitable.

Principle of convection

It is necessary to consider the basic principle of operation of the presented equipment, wishing to purchase a convector or radiator. станет понятным после проведения сравнения этих обогревателей. Which is better, will become clear after comparing these heaters.

These devices operate on a general principle called convection. When heated, warm air rises. The coldest temperatures are fixed at the floor of the room. Gradually, when the airflow cools, it again goes down.

When the heater is running, it pumps the temperature at the level where it is located. Then the principle of convection comes into force. This is how the room is heated.

The principle of the oil cooler

, следует рассмотреть подробно принцип работы каждого устройства. Asking the question, what is the difference between the convector and the oil cooler , you should consider in detail the operation principle of each device. It's pretty simple.

The oil radiator is considered one of the simplest devices, allowing to quickly heat the room. To install them do not need to use additional tools. The radiator is simply connected with a plug to the mains.

The design of this device consists of a tank, which is made of metal. Inside it is mineral oil. It flows around the heating element. In order to be able to control the temperature, the device is equipped with a thermostat. In some models, the system is provided from overheating.

The metal surfaces of the radiator, which look approximately like the edges of a conventional stationary battery, are heated during operation. From them, heat rises according to the principle of convection, circulating the room.

Convector arrangement

. Electric heat convectors with a thermostat are also widely available on sale. This device looks like a flat panel. It emits the minimum amount of heat. The main heating occurs with direct contact of air with the heating element of the device.

. On sale is a wall and floor convector heating . This allows you to mount the device as conveniently as possible.

This heater consists of a body (convection chamber) and a heating element inside the panels. Cold air enters the device from the bottom. Passing through the heater, it heats up. Warm streams exit independently through the upper convector blinds. The process is absolutely silent. This is a very effective type of heating.

Advantages of the oil cooler

масляного типа обладает определенными достоинствами. Floor heating convector oil type has certain advantages. First of all, it should be noted its low cost. It works absolutely noiselessly, and also allows you to move it from the room to the room with the help of wheels.

Such devices usually have a thermostat in their design. It determines the heating temperature and when the specified level is reached this parameter turns off the heater.

If the thermostat has a timer, you can set the time from which the device will turn on. This principle allows you to save on electricity. In order to choose the right oil cooler, it is necessary to purchase a device with a power of 1 kW for a 10 m² room (with a ceiling height of up to 3 m). A wide range of today's oil coolers will allow you to choose a device for a room up to 25 m².

Advantages of the convector

, необходимо рассмотреть достоинства каждого вида. Choosing a convector or oil cooler , you need to consider the merits of each type. Each of the devices has its pros and cons. Convector heating has several advantages.

This type of heater is fireproof. Their front panel does not heat up more than 60 ° C. In this case, users can not get burned, even touching the surface of this device.

With the help of convectors you can make a full-fledged autonomous heating. These devices are connected in a single circuit and include for heating, for example, a country house. For those who do not want to install a boiler that requires a lot of installation and purchase costs, this option will be preferable. Enough little electricity due to the presence of a thermostat consumes a convector or a radiator. выбрать, позволит понять сравнительная характеристика этих приборов. What is better to choose, will allow us to understand the comparative characteristics of these devices.

Operational characteristics

First of all, it is necessary to consider the performance characteristics of a convector or oil cooler. этих приборов довольно существенные. Pros and cons of these devices are quite significant.

The oil cooler, according to consumers and experts of electric heating equipment, consumes ¼ of energy more than the convector. This is due to the heating rate and the operating principle of the system. The oil cooler first heats the liquid inside, then the walls of the tank. Only after this, the fins of the device give heat to the environment. In the convector, the heater is directly in contact with the air.

The time needed to warm up the device requires additional energy costs. If an additional fan is installed in the device, the temperature rises faster. But the heater at the same time works with a certain level of noise.

Comfort in operation

, следует уделить внимание комфорту при эксплуатации представленных приборов. Comparing oil radiators and electric heating convectors with a thermostat , you should pay attention to the comfort when operating the presented devices. This applies to mounting and carrying the device.

Convectors are mobile than radiators. They can easily be moved from room to room, since the weight of such devices does not exceed 10 kg. Oil radiators are heavier. Their weight is 18-25 kg. In this case, the entire construction is rather cumbersome. It can not be mounted on a wall. This is always a floor type heater.

The convector can also be mounted on a wall. In this case, the wires will not get in the way, and cleaning will be much easier. If desired, the convector can be floor type. To do this, you need to purchase special stands or wheels.

Security

Comparison of the presented electric heaters must also be carried out in the context of their safety during operation. происходит по разным принципам. It should be noted that the heat transfer of the convector and radiator occurs according to different principles. The oil heater pushes the high temperature of the liquid inside. Thus the case heats up to such level, that on a skin there can be a burn if casually to touch to its surface.

Convector has the temperature of the front panel completely safe for people. If you leave such a heater unattended, it will not create a fire hazard situation. The oil cooler must never be left unattended. Otherwise, it may cause a fire in an unfavorable combination of circumstances. In the event of a drop in such a device, hot oil may spill onto the floor. Some models are equipped with special devices that prevent leakage, but not every manufacturer provides such a protection system.

Ecological compatibility

Many users make a comparison of convectors and radiators according to the principle of environmental friendliness. In this issue, you need to understand this. Since both heaters have the principle of their work being convection, the dust will rise up in any case. It is invariably picked up by streams of heated air. With this fact it is necessary to reconcile, acquiring a convector or radiator.

Also it should be said that some sellers of the presented technology claim that these heaters burn oxygen. However, according to the laws of physics, this process is impossible even in an oil cooler, not to mention the convector.

Service life and cost

Different lifetimes are characterized by a convector or radiator. , помогут отзывы экспертов о продолжительности эксплуатации приборов. Which is better , the experts' feedback on the duration of the devices will help. Oil radiators are much inferior to convectors in this parameter. Their service life does not exceed 7 years at best. First, a small crack forms in the body of the device. Then it grows, and through it oil flows out. Then such a heater can simply be thrown away.

Convector operates on average from 10 to 15 years. Thus manufacturers give a guarantee on the products about 5 years. This is a significant advantage of the convector over the radiator. It is worth noting that the quality of the device should not be saved. Oil radiators are much cheaper than convectors. But this is the only point on which the equipment presented wins.

Having considered the main characteristics of the presented heaters, and also comparing their advantages and disadvantages, it is possible to name an unequivocal winner. Almost all indicators are leading the convector. Let its cost be slightly higher than that of an oil cooler, but reliability, safety and comfort in use outweigh the price index.